Director: Leander de Cordova Year: 1925 Rating: 5.0
The novel She
written by H. Rider Haggard in 1887 is a wonderful read. From time to time,
I pick up a book written in the 19th century and more often than not surrender
after about 100 pages. But this one kept me going with Haggard's imagination
and an exciting narrative. It was a highly influential work in the adventure
genre. It was a natural for the cinematic screen and there were five shorts
produced before this feature film running 96-minutes. The 1935 version with
Randolph Scott and Helen Gahagan is terrific and then there is the best known
one, produced by Hammer in 1965. This one is a British-German production
and it is sorely lacking in excitement, glamour, imagination and grandeur.
It is quite dull actually with poor acting and only saved by the story and
the sets. That impression isn't helped by the version I watched that is lacking
in visual detail. I read that a tinted version was released on dvd but the
duration given is only 74 minutes.
Horace Holly (Heinrich George) is sitting
comfortably in his lodgings at Cambridge University when his friend Vincey
bursts into his room with a small request. I am dying. Could you become the
guardian of my son? Sure. Why not. I will leave this package with you to
be opened when Leo is 25. Ok - but perhaps you should go to a hospital. That's
what I would say but Holly - nicknamed the Baboon which seems cruel - just
lets him go and sure enough he soon dies. Jump ahead to Leo's 25th birthday
- he is grown-up with a big shaggy blonde wig and no personality - played
by Carlyle Blackwell. With a name like that he should be playing whist in
a men's club, not acting. The father left his son a message that there is
this mysterious magical woman in a lost civilization in Africa and he should
go. And off Holly, Vincey and their poor manservant Job go. This is pre-internet/pre-phone
mind you, so difficult making reservations. How did people do anything back
then. I honestly, don't recall.
They make it to Libya where a ratty dressed
tribe picks them up and takes them to their cave. They are all very excited
because it is hotpot for supper! I am not a fan of hotpot, especially with
human meat in it. But they are saved by the priest, Vincey gets sick and
Holly meets . . . The Woman Who Must Be Obeyed. Which I thought was my girlfriend.
Ayesha has lived for 2,000 years waiting for the reincarnation of her lover
Kallikrates - who she killed all those years ago. Oops - and now is waiting
by his dead body every night. She is so beautiful than any man who sees her
unveiled face falls in love and becomes a supplicant. Holly is quickly down
on his knees.
Now with Ursula Andress in the 1965 version
I could believe that but with Betty Blythe - not so much. Even in her see-through
garment. She was a movie vamp in her day wearing as few clothes as legal
in her films - but to the modern eye, she is kind of doughy and dumpy. Turns
out Vincey is in fact the reincarnation of Kallikrates! Lucky man! Eternal
life promised. Though living in a spacious cave could get boring. No wonder
the first Kallikrates had a wandering eye. At the end of the film,
Ayesha promises to come back reincarnated, more beautiful than ever - and
that would of course be Olga Schoberova in the 1968 Vengeance of She.