Mr. Holmes Film Review
Mr. Holmes
Director: Bill Condon
Year: 2015
Rating: 7.0
At the age of 49, Sherlock Holmes retired to
Sussex Downs as Doyle recounts in His Last Bow.
"But you have retired,
Holmes. We heard of you as living the life of a hermit among your bees and
your books in a small farm upon the South Downs.’ Exactly, Watson.
Here is the fruit of my leisured ease, the magnum opus of latter years!”
He picked up the volume from the table and read out the whole title, Practical
Handbook of Bee Culture, with Some Observations upon the Segregation of the
Queen."
There have been stories written by others
about Holmes years in Sussex, in particular a series of books by Laurie King.
This film though is based on A Slight Trick of the Mind by Mitch Cullen.
It is a sad and melancholic film of Holmes in his final chapter. Ninety-three
years old, unsteady of step and uncertain of mind. His friends and brother
have passed and his memories are slowly escaping. But they still haunt him
even if cloudy. He grabs for them in bits and pieces. He still takes care
of his bees and has a housekeeper and her young son. Elegiac as it deals
with old age and what comes with that. The great Sherlock Holmes searching
in his mind for words and writing people's names on his shirt sleeve. It
hurts to see because he is Holmes.
Played brilliantly by Ian McKellen who was
73 at the time but easily adds twenty years with makeup, speech patterns
and a stiff creaky walk. There is no mystery in the film; only regrets over
the past. He fixates on what was his final case (told in flashback) and what
happened that drove him to retire, but the details won't come. And an instance
in which he journeyed to Japan looking for a plant to help his memory but
finding a mystery instead. These two cases meander carelessly through his
mind slowly coming into focus. In another flashback, he goes to the movie
theater to see a Sherlock Holmes movie. He calls it dreadful. The actor playing
him is Nicholas Rowe, who was Sherlock in Young Sherlock Holmes. He can still
be brilliant at times as when he looks at the housekeeper and surmises where
she has been, but the darkness is creeping in. The certitude of ageing and
death for all of us hovers throughout like a fine mist. The housekeeper is
played by Laura Linney and the Japanese gentleman is Hiroyuki Sanada. It
is slow moving, a near dirge but masterly acted and shot. Directed by Bill
Condon, who also directed McKellan in the wonderful Gods and Monsters in
1998.