Reviewed by YTSL
A central character whose first words only
get heard after we have gone some 27 minutes into the film (Aggie, a Hong
Kong woman, is played by Japanese actress, Yasuko Tomita). A flamboyantly
dressed and idiosyncratically coifed hairdresser who looks to fit the stereotypical
image of a gay man but likes -- in sexual as well as other ways -- women
(Jordan Chan is delightful as Louie). A loving club hostess mother
who turns out to have previously been a father (Law Kar Ying's portrayal
of Emma earned him a Hong Kong Film Award best supporting actor nomination).
These descriptions of its key personae alone should establish that bundles
of contradictions abound in this cinematic adaptation by respected director
and scriptwriter Yim Ho from a novel by a popular Japanese writer named
-- rather appropriately, considering the food themes throughout the work
-- Banana Yoshimoto.
This is all the more so with my view of this quirk-laden
contemplative piece as an often simultaneously sparse, sensual and spiritual
offering. Right from the beginning, when the screen is filled with
beautiful blue moving water -- out of which shallow depths a face gradually
emerges -- and the first measured notes of its haunting instrumental theme
flood the air waves. Up until its similar, yet not identical, end
images and sounds. And in between, when KITCHEN slowly and subtly
but surely reveals its often simple sounding -- yet never banal nor stupid
-- messages; which are sandwiched by short, sharp, dramatic bursts of action
and pulsating energy (a significant portion of which surface whenever Karen
Mok, in a supporting but very eye-catching role as Louie's sometime model
girlfriend, Jenny, appears in the movie).
To state the obvious: KITCHEN is not a typical
movie, on many counts. A(nother) case in point: Though one
might expect it from its title, this domestic drama -- which has as its
heart the meeting and coming together of people who understand and honestly
care for one another -- doesn't showcase culinary skills and pleasurable
eating in the manner of "The Chinese Feast", "Eat, Drink, Man, Woman" and
"Babette's Feast" (In fact, there's actually more of that -- along with,
of course, fight action -- in "Iron Monkey" than in this film!).
Although they are not necessarily oppositional, what gets emphasized more
is nourishment for continued living -- whose source is not always, but
can be derived, from the preparing and sharing of food -- rather than hedonistic
indulgence or celebratory consumption.
I think it also worth noting that the principal
characters in this visually stunning work (whose cinematographer, Poon
Hang Sang, also lensed "Peking Opera Blues", "Centre-Stage" and "Red Dust")
focus more on the sense of smell and touch than that of taste (and -- despite
the film's being suffused with incredibly evocative music -- sounds).
Then there's their favoring of the kitchen as space in which to hang out
and exchange confidences -- even sleep (if you think this is weird, howzabout
Aggie's choosing to sleep INSIDE a refrigerator at one stage in the movie?!)
-- rather than just cook.
There is no denying that KITCHEN demands a lot
from its viewers (including a tolerance of eccentricities and patience
for unhurried unfoldings -- the second of which is NOT my strong suit --
as well as time plus attention). Neither will this approximately
2 hour long piece be to everyone's taste (But then, I don't think it was
meant to be). This is not least because this life affirming film
-- despite its starting off with a death of a loved one; an event which
sent sensitive Aggie into an extended period of immobilizing depression
as well as mourning -- is such an incredible mix of things that it can
appear to be the cinematic equivalent of an unbalanced as well as heavy
However, I am inclined to think of it as more
like an inviting as well as delicate and clean(sing) plate of combination
sashimi (complete with fiery wasabi). As such, my personal experience
of this ultimately quietly optimistic -- even if at times almost overwhelmingly
melancholic feeling -- as well as clear-eyed production is that it does
give plenty of food for thought (there may well be more meaningful advice
and observations in a single letter by Emma to Louie than can be found
in many other movies), laughter-evoking amusement and heart-warming vibes
My rating for the film: 8.