Madam Slender Plum
After having recently seen Paul Chang Chung play
the hero in two films – “The Golden Buddha” and “The Black Falcon” – it
was more than a bit surprising to see him get killed in the first minute
of this film – but there he was with a knife in his back and clearly no
tomorrows waiting for him. As it turns out though his character is far
from a hero and as the flashback evolves you are more than happy to see
him meet up with the wrong end of a sharp blade. This was directed by Lo
Wei – one of the Shaw’s most prolific directors before moving on to direct
Bruce Lee and Jackie Chan for other companies – and it has a clear sleek
design that is pleasing to the eye, but as in many of his films the narrative
feels sluggish and never gathers momentum. The main problem though is that
this film fails to go where it needs to – it holds back in middle class
safety – it takes the shell of a classic Hollywood film noire but takes
out the noire.
So Chung lays dead and his killer, the classy
Diana Chang Chung-wen, regains her composure, gets every hair back in place
and calmly calls the police to tell them that she just committed murder.
The inspector (Tien Feng) asks her why she did it and she begins to tell
the story of what brought her to this place. She was happily married to
Lo Wei with two daughters that they loved – but tragedy strikes when one
of the daughters dies and Lo Wei loses all their money and takes a powder.
Now without any means of support Chang has to move into a small apartment
with her daughter (Jenny Hu) and look for a way to make a living. She finds
a job as a waitress to put food on the table, but this lowly occupation
doesn’t sit well with Jenny who is used to her high status and nice clothes.
But the mother is determined to do whatever she can to give her daughter
a good life so that she wants for nothing – except maybe a little attention.
Soon with the financial help of her husband’s
business partner (Yeung Chi Hing), she opens a ritzy nightclub and it’s
a roaring success. Soon she and her daughter are back in their old home,
but she has become so busy that she has little time to spend with Jenny.
Any time Jenny complains, Diana just asks her what she can buy her. On
the scene comes Paul – an old boyfriend of Diana’s from long ago – and
he prowls around sniffing the aroma of money in the air. With a sheen of
insincerity that crawls over him like a garden lizard, he tries to cozy
up to Diana like a hundred dollar bill, but when she spurns his advances
he turns his attentions to the 18-year old Jenny instead and finds her
immaturity an easier target. Diana tries to warn her daughter but Jenny
throws it back in her face like a dry martini. Appearing also in a small
cameo is the always delicious Angela Yu Chien as a plaything of Paul's.
This may be ringing bells in your head. This is
largely a remake of the 1945 film, “Mildred Pierce”, with Joan Crawford
and Ann Blyth – but though the plot is very similar this movie has let
out all the blood. The tragedy of “Mildred Pierce” is that no matter how
much Mildred does for her daughter, its never enough – Veda is bad to the
bone and Mildred is never able to see this or accept it until she is crushed
by it. She just works harder, makes more money and translates this into
love for her daughter, but the bleak ending seems to mock the capitalistic
system as well as the American dream. They just don’t have the nerve in
this 1966 Shaw film to make the daughter that bad - Jenny Hu’s character
is spoiled but basically a good girl gone astray. Perhaps they thought
a daughter being so disrespectful of her mother would not play well with
a Chinese audience, but by greatly moderating her meanness and sexuality
they rob the film of its reason for being.
The performances from both Paul Chang Chung and
Diana Chang are quite good – he is a wonderful nasty sleaze behind the
polished front and Diana has a great sense of authority and tenderness
in her. As she moves first down the social ladder and then back up, one
can see her character change in the way she holds herself, the way she
walks and how her makeup is applied – when she patrols the nightclub and
greets the customers it has a real feel of vérité to it.
She also looks great in her assortment of cheongsams that are built to
accentuate her womanly curves and make her chest look like its ready for
takeoff into space exploration. With a more focused and nastier script,
she could have rocked this film.
My rating for this film: 5.5