Lover's Destiny
 
                                  
Director: Chor Yuen
Year:  1975
Rating: 4.0

When you think of Chor Yuen in the 1970s, the first thing and generally the last thing that will come to mind are his graceful classic wuxia films, but in between those he directed other types of films. The influential big hit House of 72 Tenants, the melodramatic Sex, Love and Hate, Hong Kong 73 was a contemporary look at the tough times in the city and then there is this misfire. He is also credited with the script so it is hard to blame this on his being forced by Shaw to make it. It begins as a comic romance that seems too sweet but then slowly changes into a nasty sour film seared with hopelessness till a nihilist ending. Who needed this I wonder? I couldn't wait till the ending though I was partly amazed by Stanley Fung in a villainous role and appreciated seeing three of my favorite Shaw actresses all in one place.




It seems to take place during the Warlord years of the 1920s and Generalissimo Zhang (Fung) runs the region like his own playhouse. Especially with the ladies. He is comically crazy with his twirling moustache and bald head and his men keep having to talk him out of executing anyone who displeases him - but allow him to bed any woman who catches his fancy. Fan (Tsung Hua aka Chung Wah) comes from Hangzou to enter university. He looks much too old to be entering college but never mind that. He comes from a wealthy family and has lots of cash to help people in need. An all-around good guy. He is a hit with the ladies as well with three women becoming smitten with him like bees to honey.




One is the upper class privileged Li-shai played by cutie pie Li Ching always dressed up like a ball is taking place with her hair perfectly positioned. Then there is Xiu-Zhu (another cutie pie Shih Szu) who is a master knife thrower and along with her brother (Chen Kwan-tai) perform exhibitions in the street. Fan helps them get out of trouble with the local police (Tin Ching) and she falls for him and Kwan pledges his loyalty to him. Finally, there is Feng-Shian, a singer that he falls for like a cement block around the feet of a Mafia informer. And her for him. Yet another cutie in the form of Ching Li. She and her mother (Ou Yang Sha-fei) live in poverty but Fan helps them as well and pays for her to go to school. Ah, love. What could go wrong?



Pretty much everything. His mother gets sick and Fan has to rush home to take care of her and the Generalissimo swoops in like a vulture to add Feng-shian to his harem. She refuses till he threatens to kill her mother and forces her to drink a bottle of wine. After that it all goes to hell and gets very downbeat. At one point the Generalissimo whips her bloody. Stanley Fung? Damn, I didn't expect that. Wang Hsieh and Chan Shen are two of the Generalissimo's men but there is no action till the last few minutes. I kept waiting for Shih Szu to unload with her knives but it never really happens. It isn't often I don't like one of Chor Yuen's films but this was a stinker.